Jessica Sanchez sang “I’ll Be There” by Jackson 5 for her second song on the American Idol 11 Top 3. This is Jimmy’s choice of song. JUDGES Randy: I liked it OK. I didn’t love that for me. It was never a moment moment. It needed a moment moment moment. It was OK it wasn’t like OH MY GOD. Steven: Don’t bore us, get to the chorus. Delicious. Gorgeous. J.Lo: You came back and killed it so hard at the end.