American Idol 11 Hollie Cavanaugh Some of you may remember Hollie Cavanaugh from season 10, as she sobbed before the judges gave her a chance to sing a second song at her Austin audition. The 17-year-old cried her way through ''The Climb,'' but the judges advanced her anyway. She came back this year, but curiously, we didn't see her at all until her last-chance performance. Her big voice shone as fellow contestants Shelby Tweten and Ariel Sprague were cut.